Spicy Sweet Soul Cakes are our gateway to the past.
Growing up a secular American can be a spiritually lonely place and living in a typical American town is often like living in a cultural and spiritual wasteland.
At some point you begin to crave the gatherings, community celebrations, and spiritual traditions that our ancestors relished in.
Because my own ancestors were Northern European AND I’m a huge nature worshiper, the Celtic traditions really resonate with me. The ancient pagan holidays make a lot of sense to a nature worshiper. They are deeply rooted in the natural cycles of our world and solar system, the interpretation of these ancient festivals is flexible, allowing for expansion and creativity, and they invite you to explore the mysteries of one’s own spirituality.
Read on to explore the lore and traditions around baking Soul Cakes for Halloween.
Samhain, the original Halloween
Samhain (pronounced sow-win) is the most import ancient Celtic celebration. Because the Celtic religion followed the natural agrarian cycles it is essentially the Celtic new year. At Samhain the growing season is complete and the harvest has been collected from the field. In the Northern hemisphere the days are growing shorter and Samhain marks the start of the darker half of the year. Samhain was and still is a time to celebrate the bounty from the earth by feasting, worshiping fire, communicating with and honoring the dead, and for placing intentions for the new year.
Some of our most honored halloween traditions stem from the ancient pagan practices.
The modern jack-o-lantern comes from the tradition of carving harvest vegetables like radish, potato, gourds, and turnips into candle holders. We can only assume that this practice was a way to honor and give thanks to the harvest, while guiding the spirits from the Otherworld, and simultaneously worshiping the fire that would keep the Celtic homes warm and lit during the long winter months.
Dressing up in Halloween costumes probably comes from the ancient tradition of wearing masks on Samhain. The Celts were deeply affected by their supernatural beliefs, they recognized Samhain as the day of the year when the veil between our world and the Otherworld was thinnest. The faerie folk and souls that normally reside in the Otherworld could cross over into the land of the living to visit humans on Samhain (and vise versa!) and this frightened some early pagans. They used masks to hide their identities and to trick the faerie folk and spirits into leaving them alone!
Trick-or-treating most likely evolved from the practice of baking special food offerings for the souls of the dead who would return to feast on Samhain. As to not let that food go to waste after the celebrations it was often given to poor beggars who went door to door knocking for treats in the name of the Irish god Muck Olla. Much later the Christian church had established a three day festival to take the place of Samhain; “All Hallows’ Eve” on October 31st , “All Hallows” (All Saints’ Day) on November 1st and, “All Souls’ Day” on November 2nd. During this time the practice of going door to door to ask for a cake to save your soul was known as going “Souling”.
Soul Cakes, an offering and an amulet
I first read about Soul Cakes making a comeback in modern kitchens in Gastro Obscura. I was intrigued and wanted to create my own version of this medieval recipe. One of the earliest recipes cited in that article was from 1604 and calls for ale barm, mace, saffron, and sweet butter. Yep, they had me at sweet butter!
If they were being made in 1604 then the recipe was probably much older than that. I like to believe that they harken back to the time of the early Celts, who would make little cakes as offerings to the souls of the dead and would also use the cakes as amulets of protection.
The Sun Wheel (circle and cross) is one of the oldest spiritual symbols.
I like to think of the Celtic circle and cross as a wheel, a representation of four. The four seasons – winter, spring, summer, and fall. The four major pagan festivals – Samhain, Imbolc, Beltane, and Lughnasa. The four earthly elements – earth, air, fire, and water. The four stages of life – child, adolescent, adult, and elder. The four directions – north, south, east, and west. And the four important celestial events – the winter solstice, the spring equinox, the summer solstice, and the autumn equinox.
In the ancient ogham alphabet the cross represents the Alim (white fir tree) which was one of the nine sacred woods used to start Celtic festival fires. The fir grows straight and tall and would be a representation of strength and endurance.
The circle surrounding the Celtic cross may be a representation of the sun, the moon, a wreath or the ideas of “oneness”, “wholeness”, and “purity”.
The cross has always been used as an amulet for protection and connection. Marking the top of your soul cakes with a cross is acknowledging the connection between the physical, celestial, and spiritual realms.
A lot can be conveyed with such a simple design!
The Soul Cake process
You will find so many variations for soul cakes online. Since there was no real written recipe until around four hundred years ago (and that one doesn’t give measurements) bakers have to assume what they may have tasted like. We do know they were heavily spiced and sweetened, made with butter and leavened just a little with Ale Barm (the yeasty foam from making ale). So if looking for a recipe you will see biscuit style soul cakes, cake-y soul cakes, shortbread style soul cakes, and even thinner cracker style soul cakes.
When developing my recipe I opted for a shortbread style Soul Cake with plenty of sweet cream butter!
I used sprouted whole wheat flour for easy digestion and because whole wheat feels much more akin to the grain that traditional Celtic peoples were using.
To avoid refined sweeteners I used whole Medjool dates and my date sweetening method.
Of course I added A LOT of spice to give the Soul Cakes some intrigue and a unique deep flavor.
In place of the Ale Barm I used just a tad of baking soda to give my Soul Cakes the slightest cake like texture. In my first attempt at recreation I actually added a bit of hoppy beer to the recipe and that produced a lovely, cake-y Soul Cake. The floral aroma from the beer was lost in the spice though, so I decided on more butter instead!
I used the back of a butter knife to score the top of each Soul Cake and then left it bare or decorated it with raisins or pecan pieces. You can get creative with your toppings and even add dried fruit and nuts to the cake itself if you wish!
So in the spirit of Samhain and honoring our ancestors, I hope you enjoy my nourishing rendition of the ancient festival food, Soul Cakes!
These soft shortbread like cakes are richly spiced, sweetened naturally with dates, and made with whole sprouted grains. With these Soul Cakes the spirits and mortals alike will be delighted and appeased durning a traditional Samhain feast!
- 1 1/2 Cup Sprouted Whole Wheat Flour
- 2 Tablespoons Ground Cinnamon
- 1 Tablespoon Ground Nutmeg (1 whole nutmeg freshly ground is best)
- 1 Teaspoon Ground Cloves
- 1 Teaspoon Allspice
- 1/2 Teaspooon Baking Soda
- 1/2 Teaspoon Salt
- 1 Cup Cold Unsalted Butter (I like the organic cultured style)
- 12 Whole Medjool Dates (pitted)
- 1/4 Cup Raisins (if desired)
- 1/4 Cup Pecan Pieces (if desired)
Preheat your oven to 350°.
Working in your food processsor add the flour, spices, baking soda and salt. Pulse this mixture until combined well.
Cube the cold butter and add it to the flour. Pulse again until the mixture is sandy.
Pit the dates and add them to the flour. Pulse the dates into the flour until the dough is smooth and shiney and pulls away from the side of the bowl.
Line two baking sheets with parchment paper. If you have a half sheet pan they will all fit on one pan.
Scoop the dough from the food procesor bowl, each cake should weigh about 1 1/2 ounces. I used my 2 ounce ice cream scoop for this step and it worked realy well. Working one scoop at a time, roll the dough between your palms to make a perfectly smooth ball. Then flatten the ball between your palms into a thick cookie shape. Take the back side of a butter knife and score the top of the cake with a cross before carefully setting it on the parchment lined baking sheet.
Place 12 cakes on each baking sheet. Decorate the top of the cakes with raisins or pecan pieces by pushing them into the cross marks.
Bake one sheet of cakes at a time on a hot oven for 15 minutes. The cakes are very delicate while hot so let them cool on the baking sheet almost completely before transfering them to a wire rack.
Let them cool for at least 4 hours before serving.
Leslie, C. W., & Gerace, F. (2000). The Ancient Celtic Festivals and How We Celebrate Them Today. Rochester, Vermont: Inner Traditions International.
Brenzina, C. (2008). Celtic Mythology. New York, NewYork: The Rosen Publishing Group, Inc.
Richardson. (2005). Life of the Ancient Celts. New York, New York: Crabtree Publishing Company
Starhawk., Baker, D., & Hill, A. (2000). Circle Round – Raising Children In The Goddess Traditions. New York, New York: Bantam Books.
Want To Learn Everything About Sourdough?
Start with this free guide,